Queeg’s Escalating Investigations
The Caine MutinyQueeg’s efforts to impose control turn minor shipboard incidents into tests of loyalty and reveal the cost of his need for certainty.
increasing
Bearing strength in each event
decreasing
The Shirttail Order

The Shirttail Order
Rule
Queeg orders shirts tucked in and assigns Willie the role of morale officer, tying the ship’s appearance to his idea of discipline.
Effect
The crew complies because it wants liberty, not because the notice changes its view of the captain.
The General-Quarters Punishment

The General-Quarters Punishment
Incident
Queeg finds sailors without helmets and life jackets during a drill. He demands their names, then penalizes the whole crew when they protect one another.
Effect
A safety exercise becomes a contest over obedience, increasing the crew’s resentment.
The Water Famine

The Water Famine
Punishment
Queeg cuts off personal water use for two days after an increased water-consumption report. Heat and stack gas make the measure especially punishing.
Resistance
The crew secretly draws water from the engine-room supply. Maryk objects but ultimately enforces Queeg’s command rather than openly defying it.
The Strawberry Inquiry

The Strawberry Inquiry
Investigation
After a quart of strawberries disappears, Queeg orders testimony, searches, and the collection of thousands of keys, certain that a duplicate key will reveal a culprit.
Dispute
Ducely and the yeoman identify the mess boys as the likely explanation, but Queeg refuses evidence that would dissolve his chosen theory.
The Search Collapses

The Search Collapses
Evidence
The search produces no key. Once Queeg abandons supervision, the crew turns the return of the keys into an unruly carnival.
Turning Point
Maryk reads his secret log and decides that Queeg’s conduct may require action under the Navy regulations.
Soon after Queeg takes command
During the convoy voyage to San Francisco
During the hot voyage from Kwajalein toward Funafuti
At Ulithi, before the typhoon
During the search at Guam